Jennifer Settle Saught by FBI in 11-Year-Old McKenna Butcher’s Kidnapping

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

GREENVILLE COUNTY, S.C. (BFMG) — The Greenville County Sheriff’s Office is seeking the public’s help to locate McKenna Butcher, a missing child whose case has remained unsolved since 2019. Then 11 years old, McKenna was allegedly abducted by her mother, Jennifer Lea Settle, after a family court awarded full custody to her father, Michael Butcher.

McKenna, who would now be 16, was last seen on April 25, 2019, in Taylors, South Carolina. According to officials, her mother, Settle, was issued an arrest warrant by the state of South Carolina on charges of custodial interference. Shortly after, a federal warrant for unlawful flight to avoid prosecution was issued by the U.S. District Court, District of South Carolina.

McKenna’s story has been featured on several national crime shows, including America’s Most Wanted and In Pursuit With John Walsh, in efforts to raise awareness and hopefully generate leads. The case was also highlighted on the Wanted by the FBI podcast, where Special Agent Robert Hamod shared details of Settle’s last known whereabouts. According to Hamod, Settle reportedly told friends in Maryland that she planned to disappear and would not be heard from again, suggesting that she might have even left the country.

Described as a White female with light brown hair and blue eyes, McKenna was 4’8″ and weighed 85 pounds at the time of her disappearance. On a website dedicated to his daughter, Michael Butcher claims that McKenna was first taken by her mother when she was only 8 months old and was raised under the name McKenna Settle, knowing little about her father. Michael eventually located her in Greenville, South Carolina, and pursued visitation rights, leading to a court granting him full custody. Shortly after this decision, Settle allegedly fled with McKenna.

The FBI and the Greenville County Sheriff’s Office urge anyone with information about the whereabouts of Jennifer Settle or McKenna Butcher to come forward. Tips can be submitted by calling 911, the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children at 1-800-THE-LOST, or Crimestoppers at 864-23-CRIME, where tips can remain anonymous.

With the help of dedicated law enforcement efforts and national exposure, McKenna’s father hopes to reunite with his daughter. The renewed focus from shows like America’s Most Wanted could be a key to bringing McKenna home and providing her family with the closure they’ve long sought.

For updates and more information, please visit the Find McKenna Butcher website or follow the hashtag #McKennaButcher on social media platforms.

Powered By EmbedPress

Copyright 2026 Blunt Force Media Group, LLC. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Share this article

TIPS AND INFORMATION REPORTING GUIDELINES

Blunt Force Media Group is committed to providing a safe and confidential platform for individuals to report tips and information related to criminal activities. To ensure the integrity and effectiveness of our tip submission process, we have established the following policy:

Confidentiality and Anonymity

Confidentiality 
We take the confidentiality of our tipsters seriously. Personal information provided will be kept confidential and will not be shared without explicit consent, except as required by law.

Anonymity
If you wish to remain anonymous, you may do so. Please be aware that maintaining complete anonymity may limit our ability to follow up for additional information or clarification.

Accuracy and Detail

Provide Specific Information
To assist in the investigation, please provide as much detailed and specific information as possible, including names, dates, locations, and descriptions of the criminal activity.

Supporting Evidence
If available, please include any supporting evidence, such as photographs, documents, or recordings. Ensure that any evidence submitted does not contain malware or other harmful software.

Legal Compliance

False Reporting
Submitting false information or intentionally misleading tips is a criminal offense and may be subject to legal action. We take the accuracy of the information seriously to protect the integrity of our investigations.

Mandatory Reporting
Certain types of information, such as those involving child abuse or imminent threats to safety, may require us to report to appropriate authorities as mandated by law

Submission Methods

Online Form
Tips can be submitted through our secure online form available on our website. Ensure all required fields are completed accurately.

Phone
Tips can also be submitted via our hotline for specific cases. When a hotline for a case is established, callers will speak to a live representative who will collect the information and submit it to the appropriate jurisdiction to investigate the lead. Calls are recorded for quality and verification purposes.

Mail
For those preferring traditional methods, tips cannot be mailed to our postal address and will not be accepted.

Follow-Up and Feedback

Acknowledgment
Upon submission, you will receive a reference number for your tip. Keep this number for any future correspondence regarding the tip.

Follow-Up
We may contact you for additional information if you have provided contact details. If you wish to remain anonymous, ensure your initial submission is as comprehensive as possible.

Feedback
While we cannot provide detailed feedback on ongoing investigations, we value your contribution and will do our best to acknowledge receipt and update you where appropriate.

Data Protection

Data Security
We employ robust security measures to protect the data submitted through our platform. All information is stored securely and accessed only by authorized personnel.

Retention Policy
Information provided will be retained for as long as necessary to fulfill the purposes outlined in this policy and comply with legal requirements.

Disclaimer

No Liability
Blunt Force Media Group is not liable for any consequences resulting from the submission of tips. By submitting information, you acknowledge that you have read, understood, and agree to this policy.

Contact Us

For any legal questions or concerns regarding this policy or others, please contact us at: Email: legal@bluntforcemedia.com